The LNER Coach Association have, on their web site, a draft roofing specification, to which the intending carriage re-roofer is recommended. This covers the application of canvas, using a modern bedding material. On the Bluebell we still adhere to the old bedding compound of chalk in linseed oil.
The LMS Carriage Association have a video on YouTube showing re-canvassing.
In addition notes are provided here about the use (now considered problematic) of a modern synthetic material, as used on curtain-sided lorry trailers, and also for aluminium roofing, as applied to a couple of our more up-market vehicles. Further notes are included about "Sagging roofs".
Roofing felt has the disadvantages that it involves putting nails into the roof, and, with time it becomes brittle and does not flex as the coach body moves, so cracking, letting in water. We have in the past used it for static vehicles, as a temporary measure, but would probably now use the synthetic material in these circumstances.
"TWENTY ONE YEARS OF CARRIAGE ROOFING"
The three "BR Standards" and the two LMS sleepers apart, all Bluebell carriages have wooden roofs, as have all but one of the railway's vans and covered wagons. In this respect we are probably unique in the railway preservation field, where with few exceptions all steel BR Standard Coaching Stock provides the typical train. On the Severn Valley Railway rakes of Great Western and LMS coaches similarly have galvanised steel roofs.
A sound and watertight roof is the key to effective carriage preservation and the railway's first two decades witnessed a continuous battle with the elements.
The early 1960s were years of unprecedented modernisation on the nationalised system. Ageing carriages were being discarded at a prodigious rate and the early Bluebell acquisitions were with few exceptions nearing the end of their economic lives. Only those masterpieces of carriage constructions 1098 and 971 were to remain serviceable throughout the 1970s. Few had received general overhauls since the late 1940s. Small wonder therefore that the leaking carriage roof became a major problem in the formative years of the railway. The Chesham Set, which formed the backbone of the service fleet from 1961 to 1965 was particularly bad in this respect and its complete demise the following year was a direct result of the failure of the roof-covering over many years leading to rotten partitions, roof boards and a decaying moquette.
No easy solution to the problem was forthcoming for the railway was devoid of covered accommodation and wholesale re-roofing could not be contemplated. The early working membership was bereft of specific experience of railway carriages and the first "re-roofings" were undertaken with a domestic type of roofing felt, 1050 and the Observation Car being two of the vehicles so treated. This covering with its many joints proved brittle and unsatisfactory, when applied to a wooden bodied railway carriage which tends to move or "work" on its underframe, particularly in advancing age.
As the decade wore on the problem became more acute as more and more vehicles succumbed, 1098's roof covering was such that the vehicle could only be used at times of extreme pressure and 6575 developed a tendency to leak in the vicinity of the first class compartments.
Worse the prestigious LBSC Directors' Saloon was leaking with well nigh irreparable damage to the ornate lincrusta ceiling. With no prospect of covered accommodation for carriages the problem was rapidly assuming crisis proportions, when in June 1968 the Carriage and Wagon Superintendent of the day, Norman Gillett, an architect by profession, approached the Turnerised Roofing Company, a firm which patented a process not unknown to the building industries. Briefly it involved the bedding of a cotton cloth in a hot bituminous solution, the whole roof subsequently receiving several coatings of the same solution.
Although never previously applied to railway carriages, the process had several attractions, not least the minimal preparatory work that was required and the three year guarantee afforded by the contractor. Roof furniture could remain in position and scarce volunteer labour might be redirected to other aspects of carriage restoration.
The first victim of the new process was the Directors' Saloon, which received the full treatment at a price of £78. 6575, the Observation Car and several other vehicles followed with an impressive measure of success. For a time it seemed that the battle might have been won. It gradually became clear, however, that a permanent solution to the problem was as elusive as ever. By 1972 leaks had reappeared, particularly around cant rails, where water would continue to get behind the cloth, causing it to lift. Further disintegration of the original covering occurred, if anything hastened by a reaction with the bitumen inherent in the Turnerising process.
1973 was a crucial year. In the course of its long restoration Bulleid Open Third No 1482 had its entire roof completely stripped of its former covering and was submitted to the Turnerising process with indifferent results. The covering proved too thin and brittle to cope adequately with the expansion and contraction between the roof boards. In service it has proved a constant source of anxiety to those concerned with the day to day maintenance of the carriages. Armed with the knowledge that the Severn Valley had recently recovered the roof of one of the two Southern "ex-Longmoor saloons", it was decided to experiment with this process, which although more expensive had served the railways well over many years.
As in so many other fields in the early "seventies" it was the Bulleid Society who took the lead, when it agreed to fund the recanvassing of Coach 5768. A specially treated, close-woven canvas was ordered, together with the necessary bedding down compound, eight "nine kilo" cans being necessary for the one roof.
At that time the department did not posses sufficiently tall trestles or indeed the working space to enable the job to be undertaken in the shed and the vehicle coupled between two other coaches was taken into platforms 3 and 4 in the station for the work to be done.
In those days a whole weekend could pass before the canvas was properly bedded down. Today with better facilities and more experience it has been possible to recanvas two roofs in a day. The "5768" operation took place on the weekend of 22nd September 1974, although for various reasons it was not to see regular service until May of 1977.
In the meantime the complete failure of the roof covering on S.E.C.R. Coach No 1098 led to that being recanvassed in 1975, the vehicle having the distinction of carrying the first "Bluebell Canvas Roof" in traffic. The result was remarkable - a hitherto damp and musty vehicle has been transferred into one which has operated without a leak in the worst conditions. To this day, only biennial repainting has been necessary.
With the canvas roof having proved its worth further vehicles received the treatment, which is now standard for all Horsted Keynes based carriages and vans. Over the years the following carriages and several vans have received new canvas roofs:
2515 (Bulleid Brake Third) in 1976 2356 (C&W Mess Coach Third) in 1977 4279 (Bulleid Brake Third) in 1978 971 (S.E.C.R. Third) in 1979 1503 (Observation Car) in 1980 6575 (Maunsell B.C.K.) and 4444 in 1981
The recanvassing of a roof is an operation which required commonsense and application rather than any particular skill, the most tedious part being the clearing and smoothing of the roof boards, once the old material is removed, an operation which takes up to 12 man-days. The actual recanvassing involves at least 8 people and care must be taken to ensure that the canvas is smoothly bedded down and any air pockets eliminated. Subsequently the roof must be painted, with at least 5 coats, and reconditioned roof furniture, together with new cant rails and rainstrips fitted. This latter operation is particularly important as care must be taken to ensure that any water will run off the roof rather than accumulating in depressions in the centre of the strip or rail.
With 21 vehicles now benefiting from canvas roofs, it might well be thought that this proven roof covering would be standard throughout the railway. Surprisingly this is not the case. Many of the "support" vehicles purchased by the various locomotive groups at Sheffield Park sport a variety of roof-coverings or none at all. Surely they are entitled to the best as the locomotives in connection with which they were acquired. Whether it is a traffic vehicle or stores van, a canvas roof is "covered accommodation".
You are recommended to The LNER Coach Association's draft roofing specification and the LMSCA's Video for full details of how to canvas a carriage roof.
Traditional coach roofing canvas: Mitco - Andrew Mitchell & Co. - web site
Bates Business Centre, The Old Brickworks, Church Rd, Harold Wood, Essex RM3 0JF
Tel: 01708 370800 (Fax: 01708 377190)
Bedding Compound (Chalk in Linseed Oil):
Roof canvas bonding: BR Spec 77 item 12, from:
T.R.Williamson, 36 Stonebridgegate, Ripon, N.Yorks HG4 1TP
Phone: 01765 607711 (Fax 01765 607908)
On the Bluebell we have used both traditional canvas, and also modern automotive plastic material, in a fire-proof grade, as used in curtain-sided lorries and the like. This material has been used for many years by some other preservation bodies, and on departmental vehicles on the old BR. It was hoped that it would give a longer life than canvas, but has caused serious problems where hot cinders from the loco have melted holes in the material. It is easier to apply, but is more difficult to avoid wrinkles. In our limited experience it works better (appearance wise) on arc-roofed stock than semi-eliptical, although both Bulleid Brake 2515 and the VCT's Matchboard Brake have worked well, as has SR van 404. It is available in a variety of colours (grey and white are the most useful for railway use) and does not need painting. The material we have used on our Metropolitan coaches has a surface texture not that dissimilar from painted canvas. It does seem to attract dirt rather more than a painted roof, that on 2515 having become a much darker grey as a result.
Warning: We are no longer using this material on traffic vehicles following experience that hot cinders from locomotives have melted holes in the roof covering on several coaches. It is, however, a very useful material for static vehicles, such as stores vans, or coaches some way down the queue for restoration. Painting the material also appears to help prevent much of the problem caused by smaller cinders. Larger cinders tend to end up rolling down until they reach the rain-strip, where a hole in the roof covering is most unfortunate. Reinforcing this area with a strip of flash-banding has provided a temporary solution.
You can obtain complete vehicle lengths of both canvas and the synthetic material in a single run. The synthetic material is made up from (two) strips, welded together, wheras the canvas may be made from more strips than this, stitched together. One other user of this material had a slight problem on one vehicle, since there was a fault in the seam (they didn't discover it until it had been on the vehicle for a good many years) and were able to partially remove the material, repair a rotten roof-board and the fault in the material, and re-fix it. Try doing that with traditional canvas!
For any re-roofing, of course, you have to start by stripping all fittings and roof furniture, as well as whatever mouldings around the edge are used to cover the row of tacks which hold the canvas on. All sharp edges and broken-off pins/screws must be removed from the entire roof surface. If the cant-rail or roof-edge where the tacks go is rotten you may need to get into structural repairs before fixing down the canvas.
Any sharp edges where the boards have warped/cupped are best sanded/planed down. Unless the gaps are serious, in which case a little filler might sort out the problem, providing you're not going to spend too long walking on the roof, some small gaps are of little consequence. If there are holes where roof vents have been removed, and if you are not replacing the roof vents, it might be as well to tack a piece of aluminium or steel sheet over the hole before re-covering the roof, although if the vehicle is to re-enter passenger service, a proper timber repair should be effected.
Traditional canvas is more labour intensive, and really needs to be done under cover in the dry. The process takes several days, since you have to allow time for each coat of paint to dry. For the synthetic material, which does not require bedding down, it should be possible for two people to complete the operation in a weekend. The condition of the ground around the vehicle will affect how much time it all takes. We have a shed with concreted surfaces, which is something of an advantage!
With either material it's best to lay the material out on the roof (or somewhere else) for some time in advance so that the creases fall out.
The best method we found for fixing the synthetic material is as follows:
Lay it out along the roof. Fix the centre of one end with a number of tacks. One person now goes to the other end, stretching the material, maintaining a straight line down the coach (it was helpful to have a seam running dead centre). Rolling the spare material around a 2-ft long wooden bar helped this tensioning process. The second person, wearing soft shoes, goes down the centre of the roof, fixing tacks in along the centre line where they will be covered by the rim of torpedo vents (if they are so positioned!), until you reach the other end, where the center can be tacked in place. If you have no such roof funrnature, this is not a problem, and there is no need to do anything but fix the two ends. We then worked across each end and along each edge, putting tacks in every three inches, ensuring that the material was not creased. It may help to put a tack in about a foot ahead and then fill in in-between. Where the material is not held along the centre-line of the roof, it may be advisable to work down both sides simulataneously.
Where you have pipes and tanks coming up out of the roof, tacks will be required. I would cover the joint with an aluminium or hardwood moulding, suitably sealed with mastic, and so covering the tacks. Fittings such as rain-strips and torpedo ventilators are fixed down with screws, and should be sealed down with either mastic or, better, arborseal.
This technique worked for us, but it appears to be very much more difficult to avoid creases in the synthetic than in the traditional canvas. This is the reason I recommend the synthetic more for arc-roofed vehicles, since any creases are less visible than on the near vertical edge of a semi-eliptical coach roof. However, it appears that, with time, minor wrinkles in the synthetic material become less noticable, and we were well pleased visually with the result on both our Metropolitan coaches and the LBSCR Bogie First, until the cinder holes appeared! The SR Passenger Luggage Vans which have received this covering also look good. We are now intending to re-cover the roofs of the first two metropolitan coaches with traditional canvas, and the third carriage has already been done in this manner.
In 1997 we were using both methods - our two Bulleid Brakes' roofs were re-covered that year, one with each material, so we should be able to perform a long-term comparison. The roof canvases seem to start leaking after typically 15 years, and replacement rather than patching becomes necessary after 20 years. This period will tend to be shorter if the carriage body is in less than first-class structural condition, since the working of the wooden structure will tend to open up cracks in the paint covering the canvas.
Costs: The synthetic material (in a suitable fire-proof grade) costs a similar amount to traditional canvas (in the region of £4-500 for a 60-foot coach), but the latter ends up rather more in total due to the costs of the bedding compounds.
Manufacturer: We have obtained the synthetic material from:
Mudfords (Sheffield) Ltd
400, Petre St
Sheffield South Yorkshire S4 8LU
Tel: 0114 243 3033
The other roofing technique not previosuly discussed, is aluminium. This we have used on Pullman Fingall and the GNR Directors' Saloon. It is also used by the VSOE on their wooden-bodied Pullmans. Traditionally the ends of Pullmans were covered in shaped copper, with the central, straight, section of the roof canvassed. Doing the whole roof in relatively narrow aluminium strips off a roll is expensive, especially when it has to be shaped at the ends. However, it is not a ridiculous cost, and should be rather more durable than canvas. The joints are screwed, and bedded down with arborseal; ordinary mastic will tend to work out of the joints, giving rise to leaks.
This is a frequent "feature" of old arc-roofed coaches. Even the eight-foot spans between partitions on our Brighton bogie first show signs of sagging. It doesn't necessarily mean that there's anything major wrong with the roof. Particularly in a vehicle which has had internal partitions removed, this may happen, and can usually be rectified by gently jacking up the inside with a suitably shaped support on acro-props, and then re-inserting a partition, or, if you wish to keep the interior open, some extra, deeper roofing sticks, as we have applied to the interior of the luggage area of Metropolitan coach 387. Note that as the roof is jacked up the sides must be free to come back in to their original width.
On one vintage carriage where the roof had sagged slightly between partitions and where the roof had to be removed in any case, it was decided to re-profile the oak roof-hoops by steaming them and clamping to a curved former. A wallpaper stripping steamer provides the steam, and the roof hoop is enclosed within a flexible drain-pipe or flue-tube liner etc. About 1 hour steaming was required for re-tensionning an existing curved member, but rather more would be required before bending new timber (allow at least an hour per inch of cross section). Laminating and glueing together thinner more flexible sections is another useful technique for making roof hoops.